EU approves unsustainable catch limits for deep-sea species

All Press Releases…

Deep-sea species are especially vulnerable yet newly established TACs ignore scientific advice.


November 30, 2010
Madrid
Contact:
Marta Madina ( mmadina@oceana.org )




Oceana expresses dismay at the commercial exploitation of 22 other species without any management measures and using destructive fishing gear.

Oceana believes that the Total Allowable Catches (TACs) approved by the Council of Fisheries Ministers of the European Union are insufficient to ensure the sustainable exploitation of deep-water species. The regulation on fishing opportunities, reached yesterday afternoon, aimed to slightly reduce or maintain current TAC levels for 2011 and 2012. The regulation also ignores more than 20 vulnerable species, which will continue to be fished without any management measures.

Oceana supports the new regulation maintaining the 2010 TAC of 0 tonnes for deep sea sharks, including 4 new species, and the orange roughy. However, the organization regrets the decision not to ban incidental deep-sea shark catches in 2011, and incidental orange roughy catches in 2011 and 2012.

With respect to other species included in this regulation, Oceana is deeply concerned about the null or minimal reductions adopted, particularly in those cases where explicit scientific advice was ignored. Indeed, for species such as the black scabbard fish and the sea bream, TACs exceed scientific advice by 15% and 56%, respectively. For other species like the alfonsino, grenadier, blue ling and codling, the approved reductions between 0% and 13% are inadequate, since there is still no scientific evidence that their exploitation is sustainable.

"The slow growth rate, late maturity and low fertility characteristic of these species cannot withstand high operating levels,” said Ricardo Aguilar, Director of Research for Oceana Europe. “Their management must, now more than ever, follow the precautionary approach.”

Both the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES) and the Scientific, Technical and Economic Committee for Fisheries (STECF) have recommended, due to the precarious situation of most of the stocks, a significant reduction in the catches of these deep-sea species, until the evolution of the stock sizes shows a positive trend.

Another problem is the current commercial exploitation of 22 other deep-sea species without any management measures. Although theoretically these species are occasionally caught in small quantities, they are equally vulnerable, and their exploitation should therefore have been regulated and included into the final regulation.

"The impacts of these fisheries are significant, as they cause the physical destruction of important habitats such as seamounts and deep-sea reefs,” added Javier Lopez, marine scientist at Oceana. “Also deeply troubling is the capture of bycatch species. Some fisheries catch more than 70 non-target species."

Main scientific advices ignored by the Council in this Regulation for 2011 and 2012.

 

 

Species Name

ICES Area

TAC (tn)

2010

ICES Recommendation

(tn)

TAC (tn)

2011

TAC (tn)

2012

Black scabbardfish

(Aphanopus carbo)

I-IV

12

 Reduce catches

12 (±0%)

12 (±0%)

V-VII, XII

2547

<2000

2356 (-7,5%)

2179 (-7,5%)

VIII-X

3348

<2900

3348 (±0%)

3348 (±0%)

Alfonsinos

(Beryx spp.)

III-X, XII, XIV

328

Reduce catches

328 (±0%)

328 (±0%)

Blue ling

(Molva dypterygia)

II, IV, V

56

Reduce catches

56 (±0%)

56 (±0%)

III

11

Reduce catches

11 (±0%)

11 (±0%)

Red seabream

(Pagellus bogaraveo)

VI-VIII

215

Reduce catches

215 (±0%)

215 (±0%)

IX

780

<500

780 (±0%)

780 (±0%)

X

1136

<1050

1136 (±0%)

1136 (±0%)

Forkbeards

(Phicys blennoides)

I-IV

31

Reduce catches

31 (±0%)

31 (±0%)

V-VII

2028

Reduce catches

2028 (±0%)

2028 (±0%)

VIII-IX

267

Reduce catches

267 (±0%)

267 (±0%)

X, XII

54

Reduce catches

54 (±0%)

54 (±0%)