Island of Patmos

August 9, 2008

Concha Martínez

Yesterday we anchored off the Greek island of Patmos. It is a small island, but from the ship it looks like your typical postcard of a Greek holiday to us. There are several craft of different sizes anchored like us.

Since Thursday, we have been getting strong winds again. At times, they have reached force 8, which on land means that the wind blows from 60 to 70 kilometers per hour, and in sea terms, it is called "gale (strong wind)". Fortunately the gale has not been constant enough to cause "big waves" as usually occurs. In any event, this wind has prevented any attempt of icthyoplankton sampling as well as finding fishing boats fishing because when the seas are so rough, they don't usually come out.

Yesterday the divers made two dives, one in the morning and the other in the afternoon at two points on this island.

They tell us that they could not have been more different. This is because the places they have been were very close together. However, the first dive gave them the chance to see vast meadows of sea phanerogams, and they especially saw a large number of rabbitfish (Siganidae). Carlos, our photographer tells me that it is a Red Sea fish and that it entered the Mediterranean via the Suez Canal.

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

However, on the second dive, they found the area covered with a “plague” of mucilagous bentonic seaweed. The appearance is that the entire sea bottom, sea grass, sponges included, appears covered with an unsightly, filamentous and viscous mass.

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

Nevertheless, they were also able to see this cute family of dotted sea slugs (Discodoris atromaculata).

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

Ctenophore soup and fishermen at dawn

August 6, 2008

Concha Martínez

We continued in the Aegean Sea. The weather is great. The wind has died down and the sea is quite calm. This allows us to continue with our campaign plan without major changes.

Yesterday, at dusk, Patricia Lastra, the marine scientist who is who is working on the red tuna habitat conservation campaign in the Mediterranean, took several samples with the icthyoplankton net at different stations to the West of the island of Samothracia (Greece).

On all occasions, the initial result was a large quantity of ctenophores (a word I learned yesterday) and that I would commonly describe as some marine "animals" with a jelly-like and transparent appearance. The look a lot like jellyfish, but fortunately they do not sting.

Each of the samples collected brought up a sizeable amount in the net. We saved a few samples to examine them under the microscope and the "gelatinous soup" was returned to the sea again, as what we were searching for were larvae of other species that give us information of whether the areas where samples are taken are egg laying areas, and in that case, for what species.

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

Last night, the shifts to check whether the drift nets are used in this spot in the Mediterranean were also resumed.

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

At dawn, María José Cornax, the person responsible for this campaign was on duty when she identified a group of seven Turkish trawlers. They are probably the ones that work with midwater trawl nets to catch small pelagic fish like sardines, anchovies, mackerel... but we can't be sure of this fact. It seems they were trawling in a convoy. We have followed their course on the radar, and we have been able to verify how they have left Turkish waters, they have crossed international waters, they have entered Greek waters and then they have gone back to continue fishing in Turkish waters.

For the layperson, like me, I have also known that in this part of the Mediterranean, the territorial waters of each country (Greece and Turkey) are the waters that correspond to 6 miles of the coastline. In the rest of the Mediterranean, they are 12 miles, something that would be very complicated here because of all of the islands that there are with the corresponding country's territorial waters.

Right now, the divers are preparing to dive. Tomorrow, I will tell you about outcome of what they saw.

In Greek waters

August 4, 2008

Concha Martínez

As I had already told Keith, on July 30, the Marviva Med was arriving in the port of Athens and the little changes in the Oceana's crew that were planned for that port were made. In Athens, we said goodbye to Alberto Iglesias, one of the safety divers, as well as Keith Ellenbogen, the onboard underwater photographer since the campaign began on the Marviva Med in late May.

Another underwater photographer joined us in that port, Carlos Minguell, who was coming back from a short break, Thierry Lannoy, the diving coordinator, who also performs the functions of safety diver, and me, Concha Martínez, Oceana's Director of Development in Europe. I am joining the crew as a communications person for a few days and to learn how to help out with whatever arises.

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

The truth is that it is extraordinary to have the possibility of participating in Oceana's projects "in the field", especially for people like me. We are "office staff".

In my case, being able to join the Ocean Ranger's crew, or like now, the Marviva Med helps me to see the projects we are working on directly. This also helps me to incorporate information in grant requests which is my job in the organization.

© OCEANA / Carlos Minguell

After being in Athens for a few days waiting for the weather conditions to be favorable so we could go out, on Saturday, August 2, we set sail toward the Northeastern Aegean Sea. However, the winds weren't going to help us much, and we are sheltered, anchored off of Cape Sounion and in front of the Temple of Poseidon (500 A.D.) waiting for them to die down a bit to continue our course.

Yesterday, the divers went out to dive in a nearby area where they identified that there was a shipwreck fairly close to where we were anchored.

They came back satisfied from the dive. The most notable part was that the shipwreck had different fishing nets tangled in it; both new and old ones. They also documented the invading seaweed, Caulerpa racemosa, that is a tropical seaweed that has expanded in the Mediterranean, and has colonized the native marine habitats.

It seems that the weather conditions are going to help us and we are going out this afternoon.

A Place to Return Too…

July 30, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Riding along the waves of the Marviva Med research boat at 10 nautical miles per hour, looking seaward towards Athens, Greece — time momentarily paused as the air grew still and the sea turned clear as glass. Within the stillness arrived a pod of dolphins that surfed the waves along the boat.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Looking down from the bow, during this surreal moment — that felt like an eternity — we danced in a mental dialogue of non-verbal communication and cerebral understanding. As the flatness of the sea vanished so did the dolphins — but I am sure they will share stories like I am with you.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As I prepare to depart to my apartment in New York City, I feel fortunate to have had an opportunity to document images and experiences with all of you. Behind the scenes, I feel even more fortunate to say that the team of people I have worked with — day and night — have become more than friends — but a close knit family bonded by a love of the ocean and passion to enjoy the place we all call home —the Mediterranean Sea.

Till my soul is full of longing

For the secret of the sea,

And the heart of the great ocean

Sends a thrilling pulse through me.

~ H.W. Longfellow, The Secret of the Sea

Over the next couple of days, while docked in Athens, Greece, the crew will change, and the next phase of the campaign will begin.

Reflections — Preparing to Depart

July 24-29, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

“There are no passengers on Spaceship Earth. We are all crew.”

~ Marshall McLuhan, writer, philosopher and communicator

As I reflect over the past sixty days at sea, on a campaign to protect the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna — our expedition has taken us to new frontiers and depths that have not often been seen. Under the direction of Xavier Pastor, Expedition Leader, we explored the Mediterranean Sea from Spain to Malta to north coast of Africa (Algeria and Libya) as well through the islands of Italy. Throughout the expedition our team has photographed/videographed some of the marine life, healthy and unhealthy, as well as illegal fishing practices. Additionally, we have been researching and sampling populations of Atlantic Bluefin Tuna larvae for further analysis.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Many of my most memorable images I photographed were in the middle of the Mediterranean Sea — as our team dove along, inside and under a cage filled with Atlantic Bluefin Tuna accelerating past our bodies to document one of the worlds most spectacular marine animals from collapse due to over fishing techniques.

Throughout the past two months — we achieved giant strides on a path that is unfortunately miles long — with many challenging obstacles ahead. While the future of the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna remains uncertain, our campaign has been successful in reaching the mass media, persuading governments to implement legislation that will help stop over fishing and illegal fishing practices of the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna and other pelagic species such as swordfish — although much more needs to be done.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

While, environmental and conservations organizations like Oceana are working non-stop to protect these precious animals from over fishing — I encourage each of you to help as much as you can by reducing your consumption of Atlantic Bluefin Tuna and Swordfish.

Traditional “Felucca” Fishing Boats of Sicily

July 23, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Off the coast of Sicily are fleets of traditional “Harpoon Fishing Boats” with cables connected to ladders connected to lookout stations — 100ft/33m above sea level — that tower over the city and mountain peeks. Defying gravity 3ft/1m above sea level with a feeling of ‘walking on water’ is a horizontal ladder extending 150ft/50m from the bow of the boat to the harpooner station.

Exclusively targeting swordfish — this selective fishing practice is a highly desirable and environmentally sound method of fishing — as by-catch (catching unwanted fish) is virtually non-existent using this method. Quickly compare and contrast this to driftnet fishing techniques that catch and kill everything and anything such as dolphins, sea turtles, etc — with 25% by-catch tossed back into the ocean as unwanted and dead.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Expedition leader Xavier Pastor encouraged our team to connect with these traditional fishermen to document their fishing practices. The next morning our three-person expedition team, departed the Marviva Med at 5am and drove north to the beautiful small town of Ganzirri, Sicily. Upon arrival, the fishermen and their two dogs welcomed us onboard their traditional ‘Felucca’ fishing boat.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Fishing near the coast within a predefined zone — the Italian captain and spotters perched sky high — located the swordfish on the surface. Once a swordfish is spotted the boat is quickly positioned for the harpooner to throw (by hand) a spear into the water and catch the fish. The harpooner is strategically extended as far forward as the cables will support from the bow of the boat so the sound of the engine does not scare the fish away.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Throughout the day the fishermen expressed immediate concerns for their livelihood—as they explained they are lucky to catch 1-2 fish a day. Embarrassed by current situation (small swordfish) but proud of their one thousand year tradition and livelihood they showed us pictures and bragged of years past when they caught numerous large swordfish. As they look to the future, they acknowledge perhaps tourism will provide them the much-needed additional income and a sustainable future.

We enjoyed our experience and meeting these fishermen!

The Oceana Marviva Med departs the Sicily tonight.

The Once Glorious Swordfish

July 22, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.”— Henry David Thoreau

The swordfish,the only member of the family Xiphiidae, are one of the most beautiful marine animals living in our oceans — with big blue eyes, a long bill and brilliant sail — its spectacular. It’s a fish so great it inspired authors such as Hemmingway and artists all over the world.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

If given an opportunity the swordfish can reach a grand size of 15ft/5m weighing 1,400lbs/650kg.

Unfortunately, the swordfish that we photographed today, being transferred from the longline fishing boat to the truck were so small that they had to pile six fish on the scale to even record the total weight of 140lbs/70kg. Cradled within the arms of a fisherman, I would estimate that some of these baby swordfish only weigh only 20lbs/9kg — just a tiny fraction of their potential size.

The swordfish population, like the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna, is endanger of collapsing. Environmental organizations are asking the general public to reduce their consumption of swordfish and Atlantic Bluefin Tuna — for a sustainable future. But also due to the high levels of pollutants in their meat.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As a warning sign our oceans are in trouble and our seas are becoming polluted — The United States Food & Drug Administration issued the following health warning for eating Swordfish:

“Pregnant women and women of childbearing age, who may become pregnant, however, are advised by FDA experts, to limit their consumption of shark and swordfish to no more than once a month. These fish have much higher levels of methyl mercury than other commonly consumed fish. Since the fetus may be more susceptible…” ( http://www.fda.gov/fdac/reprints/mercury.html )

Fishing Nets for purseiners and bottom trammel.

July 21, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

With mooring lines securely fastened to the bollard, the Oceana Marviva Med was docked in the Sicilian Harbor of Porto Di Messina, Banchina G. Marconi. From the ‘porto’ our expedition team of Maria Jose Cornax, Gorka Leclercq, and Keith Ellenbogen departed in a rental car, driving north, along the coast of Sicily to photograph fishing boats armed with driftnets in Catania, Santa Maria la Scala, Stazzo, Riposto, and Giardini – Naxos.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In all these ports we observed piles and piles of fishing nets stacked adjacent to the fishing boats — that at times were so high they blocked the view of the boats. Some of the nets were neatly stacked; others were carelessly tossed on the ground or meticulously covered by tarps. These nets are made from non-organic nylon multifilament. However, there are organic options that use silk or wool. The nets we observed were used by both purseiners, bottom trammel netters, and ferratare for small pelagic fish. We did not see any net used for swordfish or tuna.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In Italy, as part of a tradition the fisherman ‘die’ the color of the fishing nets from their original green color to red, black, orange or brown. The only explanation I can think of is — perhaps the dark colors blend into the water and yield more fish. Or dark reddish color conceals the stains of blood and dead fish when the nets are brought back on the boat. Either way there is an ironic beauty in the color, texture and pattern of these fishing nets.

Tuna Cages Bay of Milazzo, Sicily, Italy

July 20, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

With the Oceana Marviva Med stationed off the coast of Sicily we launched the Grey Rigid Inflatable Boat (RIB) to photograph tuna farms along the Bay of Milazzo.

On this expedition, Xavier Pastor, Expedition Leader and Carlos Perez, Operations / Logistics Manager informed the underwater photography/videograhy team that if the opportunity presents itself we will try to jump in the water and photograph the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna in the cages.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As we slowly approached the red buoys that covered the surface of the ocean and blocked the city in the distant horizon — we noted numerous small cages. With no boats patrolling the cages in sight Carlos Perez gave the order to myself and Gorka that we had three minutes to jump in the water and photograph tuna underwater trapped in cages.

With mask, fins, snorkels and cameras we rolled off the RIB into the cool blue ocean. To our surprise as we looked beneath the surface all the cages were empty —no nets and no fish.

Without further delay, and only one minute in the water — we returned to RIB and back to the Oceana Marviva Med.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

We are not sure why the cages were empty, perhaps the tuna were already sold to the Japanese market or maybe they were moved to other tuna-fattening cages.

Sea Mount — Seca Del Capo

July 19, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Submerged beneath the Tyrrhenian Sea is a seamount Seca Del Capo — that is 25ft/5m short of clearing the surface and becoming an island. The seamount descends to a maximum depth at the seafloor of 330ft/100m.

This seamount is well known as a fishing ground and the Oceana team of underwater explorers set out this afternoon to photograph and videograph the marine life surrounding the seamount. The underwater landscape was blue and beautiful but once again void of any large marine life.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

During our hour long dive we observed numerous schools of common small fish (damselfish and wrasses) feeding in abandoned fishing nets that have become part of the topography and an eye soar to an otherwise beautiful location.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The volume of abandoned fishing lines, nets, plastics and hooks was astonishing. At a depth of 95ft/30m I photographed a fishing hook that symbolized the sad direction for the future of Mediterranean Sea — a polluted ocean with abandoned hooks and no fish.

Vanishing into the Darkness — A 4am Expedition

July 18, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

At 4 am with only the stars and the moon illuminating the darkness of the sea — our expedition team Carlos Perez, Cesar Fuertes, Maria Jose Cornax,Gorka Leclercq, and Keith Ellenbogen rapidly descended down a vertical ladder from the Oceana Marviva Med into the Rigid Inflatable Boat (RIB) underway at 8 nautical miles per hour.

Our objective this morning was to use the RIB to get close (within 50ft/20m) to the driftnet fishing boats — and to photograph them catching pelagic fish such as swordfish or tuna.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Onboard the RIB, racing through the dark mist of the warm ocean mixing with the cool air and flat seas — we accelerated for about twenty minutes to our first targeted boat the S. Maria. In the open ocean as we approached the driftnet extreme care was taken not to let the propeller get caught in the drifting net — that was nearly impossible to see. For a brief moment, our propeller did get entangled in the net — but was quickly removed by Cesar Fuertes.

Continuing onward we arrived at the S. Maria at 4:35am and noted she had already finished hauling in the driftnet. In frequent communication with Xavier Pastor onboard the Oceana Marviva he proceeded to give us coordinates for our second targeted driftnet fishing boat the Anna Prima.

With tensions high our team carefully positioned the RIB so we were able to photograph (as best we can with virtually no light) the net being hauled in.

With the RIB underway we accelerated through the Tyrrhenian Sea towards our second targeted driftnet fishing boat the Anna Prima. During the 15-20 minutes of reeling in the driftnet we did not observe them catching any pelagic fish. Perhaps they weren’t fishing for them or maybe there were no fish left in this area to catch.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Driftinet fishing is one of the worst methods of fishing as these walls of death kill anything and everything that comes into contact with it.

Many of the Italian driftnet fishing boats aware of their illegal activities have adopted a number of strategies to avoid being easily photographed/videographed. Recently the fisherman have begun hauling in the driftnet under the darkness of night — finishing before light breaks at 5am. A second technique to avoid being photographed is to cut the driftnet and return later in the day. Lastly, the driftnet fishing boats knowing — in advance they have caught a pelagic fish— repositioning the stern of the boat to block the fish being photographed by our RIB.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As the light broke, at 5am we continued to look for other driftnet fishing boats before heading back to the Oceana Marviva Med — and picking up some plastic drifting in the Ocean.

Driftnet Fishing Boats Harbored in Lipari Island, Italy

July 17, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Anchored 15 minutes outside the Harbor of Lipari Island, this morning with a crew of five team members we launched the grey Rigid Inflatable Boat (RIB) from the Oceana Marviva Med to discreetly document fishing boats and the equipment within the harbor.

On assignment, we noted at least 10-15 fishing boats potentially masked as longliners but armed with driftnets — most likely used for illegal fishing practices. From high above the harbor we photographed a number of fishing boats with winches — a tell-tale sign they are using driftnets.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Back on the Oceana Marviva Med we immediately reported our finding to Expedition Leader Xavier Pastor. Noting the fleet of fishing boats, Xavier suspects these small fishing vessels will leave the harbor in the evening and begin fishing using driftnets during the night.

Our next object will be first, to find the fishing boats, and second, to photograph / videograph the fishing boats with driftnets in the water catching illegal species of fish such as tuna and swordfish.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In addition to photographing fishing boats, from this vantage point was an excellent birds eye view of the city.

We will depart at 4 am…more to follow.

Painting With The Moon

July 16, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

In an abstract artistic expression, this evening with the moon over Stromboli, Italy — I enjoyed painting using the light of the sun reflecting off the moons surface into my camera’s lens and onto the image sensor.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Diving in the Tyrrhenian Sea

July 15, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Eduardo de Ana

Early this morning, expedition leader Xavier Pastor instructed the dive team — left to right: Gorka Leclercq, Underwater Videographer; Josiean, Dive Master; Alberto Iglesias, Dive Master; Keith Ellenbogen, Underwater Photographer — to prepare for underwater exploration of two small Italian Islands Lipari and Stromboli.

These islands were selected as they offered an opportunity to photograph and videograph marine life living in the Tyrrhenian Sea. The profiles for both dives were similar 65 minutes maximum depth 80ft/25m water temperature 18C/70F with visibility of 80ft/25m.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

While underwater, breathing compressed air from our scuba tanks — we observed a number of beautiful living animals such as jellyfish, crabs, vibrant orange polyps, feather dusters, moray eels, octopi, as well as a green spoon worm moving over a bed of algae.

As we surfaced, with the camera still in the housing a lone Gaviota (Sea bird) stood on the rocky shore with his feathers blowing in the wind looking seaward.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In the evening as the sun was setting near Lipari Island it seemed to melt into the horizon blackening this small vertical rock that looked both like a sail or an inverted sharks tooth.

From the ‘observation’ or ‘monkey island’ deck on the Oceana Marviva Med our expedition team took a moment to pause and enjoy this spectacular part of the world — watching the sun slowly descend behind Stromboli, an active volcano, north of Sicily. Like clock work every 15 minutes the volcano had a small eruption releasing a cloud of fumes with the occasional sighting of red flames darting from the mouth of the volcano.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Alberto Iglesias

Oceana team left to right: Keith Ellenbogen, Luca, Eduardo De Ana, Patricia Lastra, Maria Jose Cornax, Carlos Perez, Xavier Pastor, Alberto Iglesias, Gorka Leclercq.

Barely Visible — Collecting Samples

July 14, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Once the ‘larvae-net’ has been raised out of the water, the microscopic larvae and small animals are sifted through a fine 500-micrometer mesh net and placed into ethanol containers. The larvae samples are reviewed onboard the Marviva Med by scientist Patricia Lastra. The larvae samples will be sent to the Spanish Oceanic Institute in the Balearic Islands, Spain for final analysis and identification.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Each time the ‘larvae-net’ is hauled out of the water excitement builds within the Marviva Med crew to discover what small animals have been caught. In one sample session I am sad to report that one piece of plastic was lifted out of the net — a reminder that pollution is everywhere within our oceans.

Continuing to look for small animals using my 105mm micro lens I photographed in a Petri dish with a steady hand a small crab and shrimp with beautiful blue eyes. Additionally, within the net we discovered two tiny fish with unusual shapes as well as some larvae that we suspect (but can not yet confirm) our Atlantic Bluefin Tuna. Within the apparent clear water there is a diversity of life just on a microscopic scale.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Consider the odds of survival — from larvae state to adulthood the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna has a 1/40,000,000 (40 million) chance to reach sexually reproductive age (6-8 years).

Sampling for Tuna Larvae

July 13, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Oceana is collaborating with Oceanographic Institute researchers, conducting essential research to sample targeted areas within the Southern Tyrrhenian Sea for larvae of the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna and other pelagic species such as swordfish.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

One of the many goals for Oceana is to utilize this data to confirm these are fertile breeding waters for The Atlantic Bluefin — and that conservation measures are needed immediately to prevent the endangered Atlantic Bluefin Tuna from becoming extinct.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Expedition Leader Xavier Pastor and lead scientist Patricia Lastra have identified a number of sampling sites within this region to survey. The procedure for inserting the net into the water is to — use the Marviva Med’s crane to raise, lower and tow the 18ft/6m long mesh nets just below the surface for10 minutes at 2 nautical miles per hour to catch larvae 3-7mm in size.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

A Walk Through Napoli, Italy

July 12, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Naples, spelled Napoli in Italian is the second largest city in Italy and the origin of the margarita pizza. Traditionally the pizza is made with mozzarella cheese, pomodoro (tomatos) and basil - each representing the red, white, and green of the Italian flag. The pizza was named after it was served to Queen Margherita when she visited the city.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Throughout the day we walked through the crowded streets of Napoli where we observed a diverse city that included romantically picturesque “vista” where restaurants and expensive yachts overlooked the volcano Vesuvius on the horizon. In contrast to the open ocean view along the harbor walkway — the center of Napoli was over crowded with people, at times trash, small cars, colorful plastic merchandise and cloths lining the skyline covering balconies of residential apartments.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With our ship re-supplied, this afternoon we departed the harbor in a continuing search for driftnet fishing boats.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Industrial Lego’s — A Shipping Container Harbor in Napoli, Italy

July 11, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

The Oceana Marviva Med research vessel docked in Pontile Falavio Gioia the cargo shipping center of Napoli, Italy — due to the size of our ship (86ft) and status as a scientific research vessel — we were unable to dock in a less industrial harbor.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Napoli is a large hub for shipping containers — and is where hundreds of containers are shipped each day carrying everything and anything all over the world. Although it appeared chaotic, it was actually a highly organized assembly line of 40 ft containers (weighing up to 3 tons each) which were then carried by trucks, fork lifts, from one location to another before being hoisted sky high on a crane that moved these containers to and from the shipping boats.

Alone in this virtual lego playground, I enjoyed photographing — and imagining the contents — these large containers from K-Line, Mediterranean Shipping Company, Evergreen, etc in a non-stop frenzy of being loaded and unloaded.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

A few interesting facts from wikipedia:

  • Today, approximately 90% of non-bulk cargo worldwide moves by containers stacked on transport ships.
  • 26% of all containers originate from China.
  • As of 2005, some 18 million total containers make over 200 million trips per year.
  • Each container shipping boat on average carries 14,500 20-foot equivalent units (TEU).

Arriving in Napoli, Italy

July 10, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

At 5:30 in the morning, as the sun began to rise over the horizon — the Oceana Marviva Med is approaching the harbor of Napoli, Italy to re-supply the ship with fresh food and fuel. Under the bright yellow light, between the Isla De Ischia on the port side of the vessel and the Island of Capri starboard side our crew continued to watch for illegal driftnet fishing boats from the bridge of our vessel.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

This is a known area for driftnet fishing boats and Maria Jose Cornax, scientist and fishing boat expert scans the horizon with her binoculars looking for any activity. Throughout the night — on evening watches from 10pm to 8am each member of the Oceana Crew spent two hours on the bridge recording any fishing boat activity picked up by our radar. Continuing our watches early this morning we did not observe any fishing boats as we prepare to dock in the Napoli harbor Pontile Flavio Gioia.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Discovering Marine Life

July 9, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

At 2pm this afternoon the Oceana Dive Team explored the underwater world around Isola Di Ponza, Italy. In calm seas protected by the leeward side of the island we descended to a depth of 100ft/30m for 60 minutes.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In contrast to the last dive where I focused on the environment — for this dive I concentrated on creating an image that captured my impression of the animal as it observed us observing them.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

While diving along a small vertical wall, we photographed and videographed many species of marine life such as moray eels, octopi, cardinal fish (the red fish) with eggs in its mouth, sea anemones and much more.

Diving Isola Di Ponza

July 8, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Onboard the Oceana Marviva Med, this afternoon at 2pm the Dive team loaded all the scuba diving equipment (scuba tanks, oxygen safety bottle, and camera/video) onto the yellow RIB (Rubber Inflatable Boat) hanging on a crane 15ft/5m over the side of the boat for a dive to Formicce — a short distance from the harbor of Isola Di Ponza.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

From the surface, before diving, we observed three fishing boats depart the harbor one after the other. The team immediately began documenting the activity and communicated our observations to the mother-ship (Oceana Marviva Med) — where we received the green light to continue our underwater exploration.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Underneath the beautiful blue water is an ecosystem in trouble. Over the last month upon returning from each dive with the excitement of photographing exotic marine animals with vibrant colors — today I thought I would show a few images that are not often seen — because they lack beauty and tell a story that we do not want to hear — reality.

While life can flourish and does flourish — the animals I have recently been observing look stressed. As our team continued the dive we observed, corals decaying, fishing line and buoys caught in rocks and disrupting the scenic landscape as well as an innocent stonefish hiding in a bed of diseased sea grass.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Masking Illegal Fishing — Covering Drift Nets

July 7, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Anchored outside the harbor of Isle De Ponza, Italy the Oceana team of photographers, videographers, scientists, and environmentalists boarded the yellow RIB (rubber inflatable boat) to in search of illegal driftnet fishing boats within the marina. Throughout the day we documented approximately 10 fishing boats with illegal driftnets — that were covered under tarps to mask their activities.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

To help clarify some of the confusion of why driftnets are used in Italy I asked our lead scientist and fishing boat expert Maria Jose to explain:

Question: Are driftnets in Italy legal?

Driftnets are legal to catch small fish such as anchovies and sardines. But….(she quickly added)

NO. DRIFTNETS ARE NOT LEAGAL IN ITALY or anywhere in the Mediterranean to catch pelagic fish such as swordfish and Tuna — what the fisherman are really catching. This practice has been banned by the United Nations, European Union, and Italy.

Question: If driftnets are legal why do we call it illegal?

it’s a legal loop hole she explained that the fisherman have been taking advantage of — to catch tuna and swordfish (illegally).

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

For example:

1. Driftnets are allowed nets with mesh opening of 18cm — but the nets mesh opening is larger then the small fish i.e. anchovies — which easily swim through the net.

2. Driftnets are allowed to fish (using driftnets) up to18 miles from the coast — but at this distance you would not fish for coastal species such as anchovies and sardines.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The only logical explanation is that they are catching great pelagic species such as tunas and swordfish — which are illegal catches when they are targeted by driftnets.

Question: How can we consider this driftnet legal when its target catches only the prohibited species of tuna and swordfish?

Its crazy and it has been documented time and time again — by a number of organizations including Oceana that they are catching tuna and swordfish with these nets.

Question: What can be done?

Oceana and a number of organizations are asking the Italian Government to eliminate this legislation and legal loop hole immediately.

It is horrifying that we have to fight our own government to save the environment. ~Ansel Adams

Exploring Sardinia’s Marine Life

July 6, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

This morning the Oceana dive team traveled an hour and half to the most southern part of Sardinia, Italy to dive around Capo Teulada (Chia Laguna), near Cagliari. With flat seas and the most spectacular turquoise blue the eye can see — we descended into the ocean below the steep vertical cliffs that ascended into the skies.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Underwater at a depth of 60ft/20m surrounded by the relatively warm waters (68F/20C) we swam over the rocky bottom into a small cavern where we discovered an entire wall colonized by bright yellow polyps (Cnidarios sp.) Also hidden within this area were a few small yellow anemones and one motionless stonefish.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Throughout the dive we also noticed in abundance an invasive species of algae from the Red Sea growing rapidly over the seafloor. This non-native species is straining an already delicate ecosystem.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The rest of the topography seemingly lay barren – as there were very few fish and invertebrates.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Sardinia — Looking for Illegal Driftnet Fishing Boats

July 05, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

At 9am the Oceana Marviva Med research vessel arrived at the harbor Nuovo Bacino Di Punete in the South of Sardinia, Italy. Upon arrival our land based objective was to look for any illegal driftnet fishing boats docked within harbors Calasseta and Sant Antioco near Cagliari. In years past, fisherman armed with illegal driftnets onboard their boats docked in these harbors — before heading into the Mediterranean off the coast of Italy to illegally fish.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

From Nuovo Bacino Di Punete to Cagliari we drove along the winding roads through the peaks and valleys of Sardinia’s mountains topography — where the suns light cast long shadows that accentuated the view from land to sea.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Arriving in Calasseta and Sant Antioco, our team discretely walked along the harbor and photographed fishing boat after fishing boat. Within the harbors we observed a variety of different boats ranging from trawlers to longliners waiting in a state of readiness with hooks, fishing line, fishing nets, reflective (marking) buoys to fish.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

In 2005 Oceana identified this area as a hotspot for illegal driftnet fishing activity. The south of Sardinia is a region with swordfish and tuna that attract the illegal driftnet fishing boats. Even driftnetters from the Ionian Sea have fished these once fertile waters.

Throughout the day I am pleased to report that we did not observe any illegal driftnets onboard these vessels. However, we remain cautiously optimistic since we have recent reports that confirm driftnet fishing boats are using these harbors.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

A Wall of Death in the Mediterranean

July 04, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

For a moment, imagine a net that descends 100ft/30meters almost as deep as the maximum depth at which recreational diver can safely descend. The length of the driftnet extends for 12 miles/20 kilometers. That is equivalent to the length of a half-marathon that takes approximately two hours to run from start to finish — if you are in good shape.

Now imagine that any living animal such as a whale, dolphin, sea turtle, shark, stingray, sunfish swimming innocently into this virtually invisible net drifting in the ocean — becoming entangled — struggling to save its life — before its inevitable slow death.

© Earth Ocean

Driftnets have been prohibited by the European Union in the Mediterranean since 2002 because it KILLS everything in its path. There are plenty of alternatives to this method i.e. longline fishing — IF and only if they use “circle-hooks” that do not catch and kill sea turtles as well as the appropriate bait to catch ONLY targeted species such as swordfish.

Other devastating affects caused by driftnets in Italian waters are:

  • 25% of the total catch — is non-commercial Meaning it has no commercial value and is dumped dead back at sea.
  • An additional 10% of the by-catch are protected species of marine animals .
  • Approximately 8,000 cetaceans (whales and dolphins) are killed each year by driftnets in Italian waters.

For more information an excellent video that helps illustrate this point is “The Business The Illegal Driftnetters” produced by Earth Ocean.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In the afternoon we observed four boats that we suspected are using driftnets.

Ausonia (4CT1055), Andrea Doria II, Ross Lucy (3CT482), Saratoka (3CT502)

"We are not going to stop until we get rid of the driftnets because it is a plague and it has been admitted by everybody, the United Nations, the national governments, everybody. There is no discussion what so ever, about the damage driftnets does and we have legislation now, we only need enforcement, so we have to push for the enforcement of those laws." — Oceana Expedition Leader Xavier Pastor.

15 hours of sunlight (6am – 9pm)

July 03, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

On the observation deck at 6:10 this morning — as I looked towards the horizon breathing the mist of the oceans morning haze I collected my thoughts and relaxed as I observed the subtle yet rapid change of night to day and day to night. With calm seas, I watched the rays of the sun dance along the surface of the fluid medium on a canvas in which ‘h20’ is the rhythm and light is the artist.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With no other vessels or land in sight as we traveled north towards Italy passing the African coast of Algeria and Tunisia — I contemplated how the ancient Romans viewed the Mediterranean as the centre of the Earth (the Mediterranean Sea derived her name from the Latin word mediterraneus meaning, ‘middle of the Earth’).

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Abruptly interrupted, on the horizon we encountered a suspected driftnet fishing boat the Alba Chiara Segunda. This vessel is of particular significance to Expedition Leader, Xavier Pastor as in 2005 the Alba Chiara threatened to attack the Oceana Ranger — because she was caught and photographed illegally using driftnets — a practice banned by the United Nations, European Union and the Italian Government for its devastating affects on the marine environment.

In part, based on the 2005 documentation submitted to the Italian government by Oceana the Alba Chiara was fined by the authorities. Our sighting of this vessel today reminds us of the uphill battle to protect our marine environment.

Dolphins

July 01, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 10am under the bright sun and flat seas we were fortunate to enjoy a brief moment watching a pod of common dolphins and a little baby surf the waves in front of the bow of our boat. One dolphin in particular seemed to enjoy swimming upside down watching us lean over the bow of the boat with camera and video lenses. They only stayed for a few minutes before heading back to the open sea.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

I don’t know what exactly to say or why everyone feels this way — but it really is a magical experience to see dolphins up-close and personal. Perhaps they feel the same way. I could have watched them all-day and wished I was swimming with them.

Tunisia Navy Boards Our The Oceana Marviva Med

June 30, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Early this morning, with calm seas, at 6 am the Tunisian Navy Warship stopped our vessel and sent a platoon of 5 men onboard the Oceana Marviva Med from a small inflatable boat. At the time we were heading innocently westward towards Algeria in Tunisian territorial sea near the island of La Galite. Over the past few days the Tunisian Navy has been monitoring our activities in International waters — along the border of Tunisia and Pantalleria Island, Italy — outside the 12 nautical mile limit from the Tunisian coast.

Throughout the past few days the Tunisian Navy would frequently call our vessel over the radio questioning our activities and motives. Due to International Maritime Organization (IMO) regulations, the Marviva Med is obligated to have our Automatic Identification System (AIS) activated all the time, so we are easily monitored from land.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Every time we changed our course or maneuvered to try to document driftnet fishing boats we received a call from the Coastguard, requesting information about our intentions and what we were doing. They do not "see" the fishing boats, as those do not have AIS. So the Coastguard station sees only the Marviva Med course suddenly doing strange turns around and changing speed and course very often. Making the Tunisian Navy curious.

Onboard, for approximately two hours the Tunisian Navy inspected the boat thoroughly and interviewed both Captain Jan Rautwaara and Expedition Leader Xavier Pastor about the boats intensions.

They were intrigued about the reason and the objectives of our research. They were concerned that we had hydrographic instruments, but we told them that our only instruments were our cameras. Xavier showed them Oceana’s 2006 and 2007 reports on French, Italian and Moroccan drfithentters and also the report "European trawlers are destroying the Oceans" (a title Xavier thought they would like). Finally they seemed to understand the purpose and the importance of the "research".

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Xavier, further explained to the Tunisian Navy how we were documenting the activities of four Italian driftnetters and how we managed to get pictures and identification of one of them while hauling in the net. The other three boats flied into Tunisian waters when they saw us. We followed them and that was when we were identified by our AIS transmissions by the Tunisia Coast Guard land station.

Since our sighting of these four driftnet fishing boats we have been constantly monitored by the Tunisian Navy. Xavier showed the Navy Officer pictures of the Italian driftnetters we have taken and asked me to prepare a DVD copy of the pictures to take back to their ship.

During the process of selecting the pictures, the photos of our cheerful crew watching the soccer European final between Spain and Germany appeared in the screen, and the situation went smoothly after this — as the officer started to smile. The crew onboard the warship had also been watching the game last night.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

They left the Marviva Med with all the information and allowed us to keep sailing. We are now proceeding to Algerian controlled waters. During the entire process Xavier asked Gorka Leclercq, videographer and myself (Keith Ellenbogen, photographer) to discreetly photograph the boat.

The situation with the control of the waters in the Mediterranean is very volatile these days. Although the international law seems to admit only the 12 miles territorial waters (no formal EEZ in the Mediterranean), there are a lot of unilaterally declared "fisheries protection zones", "environmental protection zones", "platform/continental shelf waters", where the navies and coastguards of the individual countries basically act as they want (ie allowing illegal fishing taking place if there is an agreement of the fishing companies with the specific government or making life difficult to independent observers). So we have to be extra careful in our movements.

Por fin España es Campeona!!!!

June 29, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

The Spanish “furia” team is known for its technical agility, graceful ball movement. It has had a frustrating world champion curse —preventing the national team from winning the trophy over the last 44 years. Second to the WorldCup Championship the EuroCup is the most sought after football trophy. In the final match Spain versus the favored Germans — the tides have changed and Spain returned to days of glory!

A Day to Remember! June 29, 2008; 22:45

Spain is the Euro Cup Champion — defeating Germany 1-0.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Onboard the Oceana Marviva, where the crew is international but predominately Spanish — in the expedition room — streaming the game live from the Mediterranean in Italian waters near the African coast — all activities stopped –except the watch for driftnetters in the bridge - and everyone cheered for a Spanish victory. Throughout the evening our team celebrated with a Espectacular GOOOOOOOL del niño Fernando Torres! Putting the German rivals in their place :-)

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Over the course of the expedition the Oceana team has watched each round of the cup of the EuroCup. Below sitting on the steps outside the restaurant of San Paolo Naufrago surrounded by Italians –some of them being the crew of the tuna purseiner Luigi Padre in Malta we cheered for Spain as they beat Italy in a nail biting shoot out in which San Iker Casillas blocked 2 of the 5 penalty kicks — revenging past losses.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

One of the Oceana team members, expert diver and die hard football fan, Alberto Iglesias was quoted as saying “Pensaba que nos ibamos a morir sin vivir esto… (I thought we are going to die without seeing this”)

Happy Birthday Xavier Pastor

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

From the Oceana Marviva Med Team — Happy Birthday Xavier!

In a birthday he will never forget, today his wish came true — Spain is the EuroCup champions!

The use of Driftnets to catch fish is ILLEGAL!

June 28, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Expedition Leader Xavier Pastor has directed the Marviva Med into the Italian waters South of Sicily along the boarder of the African coast heading west from Tunisia towards Algeria. Within this region near Africa, very little is known about the activity of fishermen and fishing boats. Additionally, Xavier explained to the Oceana Team that the Italian fishermen continue the illegal practice of driftnet fishing. Now with two methods of fishing under surveillance (purseiners and driftnetters) our campaign and our scope of work has broadened to include evening watches — when the drift net fishing boats are active. Each member of the Oceana team was assigned two-hour watches in the bridge from 9pm to 7am.

Driftnets also commonly known as “Walls of Death” — and is an illegal fishing practice in the Mediterranean. These nets are very long and can easily drift for hundreds of kilometers in the open sea — entangling and killing everything that comes into contact with the net.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

One of the many reason driftnet fishing is illegal is because their by-catch is frequently protected, threatened and endangered marine animals such as dolphins, whales, sharks, sea turtles, and many other precious sea creatures. Recognizing the destructive nature of this practice the United Nations in the 1990’s established an international moratorium prohibiting the use of driftnets. In 2002, they were banned by the European Union for all their boats operating in any waters. Unfortunately many boats continue to fish using the destructive driftnets.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 8:30 pm when the sun was close to setting we observed from a distance a converted trawler, now an Italian driftnet fishing boat, Federica AII (7PA1860) pulling out of the water a tuna — and is without question an illegal practice of fishing.

By documenting and reporting these illegal-fishing activities to the press and government officials Oceana is able to have a positive impact on protecting our oceans. This season we are doing it in a joint project with the Fundación Marviva.

An Everyday Fish Market

June 27, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Throughout the world every day in every city there is a fish market just like this one — that we documented in Malta Harbor at 3:30 in the morning — that brings fresh fish to your home and restaurant each day of the week 365 days a year.

No tuna are sold here — for these fish are much too valuable. Rather the tuna are processed on boats at sea and shipped directly to Japan or to your local sushi restaurant.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

But what was sold here was extremely small swordfish and what I would call baby sharks. As I walked through the market photographing the now lifeless small swordfish tossed on the floor I wondered what Ernest Hemmingway would have thought of his once great “macho” fish — that challenged man — now reduced to this embarrassingly small size. At that moment, I imagined if this were the size of all the swordfish or marlin that the ‘old man’ caught in “The Old Man and The Sea” he would have recognized it was not worthy of keeping and rather tossed it back for future generation.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

I feel there is still time to save fish populations but we must work together to change our eating habits and choose sustainable fish for consumption — and allow populations to rebuild — thus maintaining a sustainable future.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Departing Malta

Escorted by a pilot boat this morning we departed Malta harbor in search of illegal driftnet fishing boats around Sicily.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Rays of Light — Underwater Gozo and Malta

June 26, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In a twist of irony, with the absence of marine life, our exploration shifted towards underwater landscapes and prisms of light that dazzled the eye and sparked imagination.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

From the surface, and as soon as I descended, I was immediately captivated by the vibrant colors of blue and blue/green light flowing effortlessly through the water. Looking towards the surface I could almost see the change in tone of blue as I ascended and descended with the absorption of the shorter spectrum of the red wavelengths concealed in the prism of white light.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Fascinated with the landscape above the water, from another perspective, an underwater vantage point, at a depth of about 60ft/20m in crystal clear water with visibility about 25 meters — I hovered motionless, photographing the sandy cliffs, passing clouds, and curious people looking into the blue hole, in spectacular locations such as “Azure Window” and the “blue dome”.

Dive Sites Malta & Gozo

June 25, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

Exploring the underwater environment of Gozo and Malta the Oceana dive team comprised of (pictured left to right) Alberto Iglesias, Gorka Leclercq, Keith Ellenbogen, and Thierry Lannoy noted very little marine life juxtaposed to some of the most scenic locations.

Over the next couple of days we dove the following dive sites:

Gozo Island — The Inland Sea Tunnel: On this dive we descended to 80ft/26m for 80 minutes swimming through a dark underwater tunnel that extends for 240ft/80m to the dimly back lit seaward entrance. While the topography was beautiful the only sea life noted was a very small grouper (less then 8in/20cm), one lobster, and a couple of little octopi scurrying through the rocky bottom near our entry point on the inland side of the tunnel.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Gozo Island — The Blue Hole: With all our scuba diving equipment and photography gear we trekked from the car about 3-5 minutes down a rocky path to the beautiful blue hole. Aptly named for the spectacular turquoise blue water — with calm seas we descended 60ft/20m for 70 minutes.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

Malta — Tug Boat Rosi: From the Southside of the lighthouse, with a giant stride entry into the water we swam at a conservative depth of 45ft/15m for 6-8 minutes over rocky bottom with a compass bearing of 300˚. On arrival at the Tug Boat Rosi we descended to a depth of 125ft/33m where we photographed and videographed the sunken wreck.

Gozo Island — Blue Dome Cathedral and Valley. From the car, once again carrying all our scuba equipment and dive gear we descended 99 steep steps into the valley. Swimming on the surface soaking in the spectacular view of the valley as we swam 250 meters through the gorge. Underwater on our 10-minute journey to the mystical blue dome the marine environment did not look healthy.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Gozo Island – A little Island of Beauty and Mysticism

June 24, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The island of Gozo, is part of the Maltese archipelago, and is the second largest island in Malta. Gozo has a long tradition that connects — this current modern day island with the mythical island of Olygia in Homers’s Odyssey book V. Within Homer’s fabled poem, Olygia was ruled by ‘Calypso’, a nymph, (a nymph is any member of a large class of mythological entities in human female form), who detained ‘Odysseus’, the hero of the story, as a prisoner of love for seven years – who she desired to make her immortal husband — until Zeus freed Odysseus.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The Oceana team of scuba divers, photographers, and videographers inspired by the islands mythical beauty — explored the coastline as we drove from one dive site to another. With a map in hand we maneuvered through small side roads in rural areas where we observed beautiful terrestrial topography such as salt farms, caverns, cliffs, and valleys that all seemed to complimented the cool blue sea.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Along the inland sea many cliffs seemed to take on human figures and forms. Can you see the faces in both pictures?

Could this be one of the last Atlantic Bluefin Tuna?

June 23, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

“If only we could pull out our brain and use only our eyes.”

Pablo Picasso

Beneath the surface, immersed in a liquid medium at a depth of 25m/80ft in the Mediterranean Sea — looking towards the surface I watched a single bluefin tuna swimming all alone. At that moment, I felt a sense of urgency that populations are really collapsing and disappearing. Then I imagined what life must have been like only a few years ago as abundant schools of breeding bluefin tuna passed in and out of these waters on their annual migration.

Not far away armed with highly efficient and sophisticated fishing technology I could hear the obtrusive sounds of fishing boats, nets extending into the water, and the panic of the other tuna as they race to save their lives. With fishing quotas exceeded in only one month the atlantic bluefin tuna is in real danger of becoming extinct from over fishing sold to a voracious Japanese sushi market. I wonder if we can control our desire for instant financial gratification trends in cuisine to maintain a sustainable and healthy future.

Yet despite all the regulations in place the reality of over fishing and consumption is all too real. Removing all other factors (social, political, financial) if we know the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna numbers are declining then Ill ask the question — if not now, then when? — should we start to conserving and protecting this spectacular living animal for future generations. I hope its not until there is only one tuna left in the Mediterranean Sea.

On behalf of the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna I ask everyone to reduce their consumption of this precious fish and for fisherman to adhere to the European Union’s Commission decisions to stop fishing — as the fishing quotas for the year 2008 have already been filled.

“There is a sufficiency in the world for man's need but not for man's greed.”

Mohandas Gandhi

June 22, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As sure as the sun would rise, in the morning with Mediterranean Sea as smooth as glass — the purseiner fishing fleets were busy catching and caging the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna. Within 100 meters of the activity Patricia Lastra, tuna scientist as well as Gorka Leclercq, underwater videographer documented the purseiners using fishing nets. With an estimated 10,000 Atlantic Bluefin Tuna caught every day the size of these nets and cages are massive.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In the afternoon 20 nautical miles from Malta before changing course and heading to the harbor, we observed two Greek trawlers (Kentavros and Aigaion) towing a tuna cage along with purseiner from Turkey (Akgun Balikcilik 3) with a net in the water. This is highly suspicious activity since Greek fishing boats are not allowed to transfer any tuna per the June 16, 2008 EU Commission for “The Atlantic Bluefin Tuna Long Term Recovery Plan”. While we cannot confirm they transferred tuna — given their location and all the activity today — it seems reasonable to assume the boats were working together.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As we were approaching Malta the crew of Oceana enjoyed the beauty of the Mediterranean Sea.

June 17 - 20, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Under a full moon with strong winds, rough seas (category 7) and deep swells (reaching 8-12ft) the Oceana Marviva Med continue the course set by Expedition Leader, Xavier Pastor to monitor the purseiner fishing activity in the open Mediterranean Sea between Malta, Tunisia and Libya.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Over the course of the last 5 days our crew photographed and documented both legal and illegal purseiner fishing activates. With fishing boats rocking back and forth from side to side and small auxiliary boats hidden by the deep swells of the sea — the purseiner fishing fleets have a more difficult time catching the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna. The turbulent seas also impact the ability for the tug boats or trawlers to tow the massive tuna cages (once the fish are caught) against the current to their final destination.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Late Saturday night into early Sunday morning with a high pressure system overhead, suddenly the wind stopped — causing a damp mist to cover the ocean under the dark but clear moonlight sky. Unfortunately the calm seas and the fury of a closed/closing fishing season provide an opportunity for the purseiner fishing boats to re-organize and begin their over exploitation of the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna. That evening on the radar screen we observed 10 purseiner fishing boats within 1-2 nautical mile radius of our boat as well as a buoy marking a longline stretching possibly tens of miles alongside the starboard side of our boat.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As I left the bridge and looked at the stars on the horizon, I wondered how much longer can the sea sustain this assault.

The Fishing Season is Now Closed

June 16, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As of June 16, 2008 the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna (Thunnus Thynnus) fishing season has been officially closed in the Mediterranean by the European Commission due to non-compliance by member states within the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna Recovery Plan.

Read the European Commission Press Release

Government officials, scientists and non-profit organizations have estimated that the fishing industry in just 30 days has already reached the quota of 29,500 tones of Atlantic Bluefin Tuna. Recognizing there is not an endless supply of Atlantic Bluefin Tuna, the European Commission closed the fishing season — ahead of schedule — to allow the remaining breeding bluefin tuna in the Mediterranean to reproduce for a sustainable future.

Looking to the future one thing each of us can do — that will have a positive impact for the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna and the marine environment — is to reduce our individual consumption of the endangered Atlantic Bluefin Tuna.

Departing Malta — In Search of Illegal Fishing

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As we depart Malta our campaign objective to protect the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna from over exploitation and fishing is now more critical then ever. With fisherman capable of catching over 10,000 breeding Atlantic Bluefin Tuna each day — it is imperative that populations are protected for future generations.

Expedition leader Xavier Pastor explained to our team that tensions are high between international regulatory agencies and the fishing industry. From the fisherman’s point of view the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna is a commodity and one that is very valuable. While we are optimistic the European industrial purseiners will stop fishing the likelihood is they will continue to fish — but now ILLEGALLY.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Thirty nautical miles from Malta we observed and photographed the following fishing boats: Luigi Padre (TP 762), Essaida Jannet (SF 2541); Abr Albihar (1408), Maria Antonietta (SA 57), SP 250, Abr Albihar (1407), Serter Ahmet 1. Two of the fishing boats had nets in the water and the others appeared to be searching for additional schools of tuna.

In the late afternoon, our small team of photographers and videographers prepared to depart in the grey rubber inflatable boat (RIB) for a closer inspection of the fishing fleet. As we were descending the ladder onto the RIB the Luigi Padre from Italy sailed within 10 meters of our boat – no words were exchanged just a close inspection. In the RIB Cesar Fuertes, Operations Coordinator looks onward as we navigate in close proximity around a number of fishing boats — illegally fishing in the case of the Italians.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Throughout the night we will continue to monitor their activity and report their actions to the proper authorities.

© OCEANA / Cesar Fuertes

Isla Pantellería

¡Buen buceo! - Good Dive!

June 10, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 8 am the dive team assembled for our first dive in the Mediterranean as a team. From Left to Right Keith Ellenbogen, underwater photographer; Alberto Iglesias, Diver Master; Enrique Talledo (Kike ), underwater videographer; Thierry Lannoy, Dive Master; and Carlos Perez, Operations Manager.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Our dive objective was to remove fishing net that was caught in our propeller while we were anchored in Ibiza — by a careless tramelnet fisherman. About a week later in the perfectly calm bay of Isla Pantelleria Thierry and Alberto removed the entangled fishing net with two knives. Kike and myself photographed and documented the work.

© OCEANA / Patricia Lastra

 

Wearing a 7mm wetsuits, one a time, we gracefully jumped 15 ft off the Oceana Marviva into the crystal clear and cold (68˚F 20˚C) water. My Sea & Sea underwater housing and strobes were lowered with the RIB (Rubber Inflatable Boat) into the Med.

Immediately after removing the net we changed tanks and went for an exploratory dive along the rocky shore of Isla Pantelleria. From the RIB wearing our scuba diving equipment we rolled backwards into the water and slowly descended into the vibrant blue ocean.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The clear water and rocky bottom was covered with a deep green sea grass. With the exception of a few small wrasse, I did not see any fish. However, looking under a couple crevices I found a large spiny lobster moving his antennae side to side.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Even though we didn’t see many fish — it’s a great feeling to be immersed and weightless — and after about 40 minutes at a maximum depth of 50ft we ascended to the surface feeling rejuvenated.

In the afternoon the Oceana Marviva set a course for Malta. We should arrive tomorrow.

Isla Pantellería

June 9, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

One hundred nautical miles from Malta, last night we anchored in calm waters adjacent Isla Pantelleria. This defining features of the island are beautiful steep vertical cliffs and a strong angular landscape.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With a half moon visible in the clear skies, expedition leader Xavier Pastor asked the dive team to prepare our equipment for a morning dive. More to follow….

A Nautical Mile

June 8, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

After approximately 36 hours of rough seas and traveling 400 nautical miles we entered the unusually calm Sicilian Sea.

A sailors trivia: a nautical mile referrers to one minute of latitude (1/60) of arch, along the Earth’s meridian (line of longitude). One nautical mile = 1,852 meters or 1.15 miles.

Of equal interest the speed at which a ship is traveling is referred to as a ‘knot’. The term ‘knot’ originated as sailors used to tie a knotted rope to a “log”. The ‘log’ was then thrown into the ocean and the numbers of knots on the rope were counted as they passed into the ocean over a given time.

Our ship continues to sail through the night.

Rough Seas Make Good Sailors

June 7, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Enrique Talledo

Early this morning with grayish blue skies predominant wind changed direction and is now blowing from the North. With the force of the winds the sea condition changed from calm to moderate/rough. Now swelling with some force (5 -8 ft), the sea swayed the boat, the people and all the equipment from side to side. Starting to get our sea legs each of us found ways of suppressing the feeling of the swaying seas. Sitting on the observation deck, looking towards the horizon, I watched the turbulent winds create abstract forms as it passed through the fraying blue nylon rope and the hair of one of Oceana’s Scientists.

Throughout the night the swell of the seas continued — and anything not secured slid onto the floor.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The Med

June 6, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With the sun closing in on the horizon, at 8pm the Oceana Marviva departed the beautiful island of Mallorca and is now heading approximately 500 nautical miles southeast through the Mediterranean to Malta (an independent country since 1964). Sailing at an average speed of 8.2 knots per hour the voyage is going to take 72 hours and cover 500 nautical miles.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Mallorca is famous for its fancy sailboats and yachts and as we departed we passed an elegant but small sailboat heading into the marina with the famous cathedral in the background as well as one of the largest yachts I have ever seen extending at least 300ft (owned by late Onassis).

A Visit to Palma de Mallorca Aquarium

June 5, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As we woke up this morning the Oceana Marviva was docked in the harbour of Palma de Mallorca. With the afternoon to explore the island, Enrique Talledo, Oceana’s underwater videographer and I traveled to Palma Aquarium (www.palmaaquarium.com).

© OCEANA / Enrique Talledo

 

Upon arriving at the aquarium we introduced ourselves and were fortunate to be invited on a behind the scenes tour from Michael Gradel, Assistant Curator. For the next couple of hours he walked us through the various galleries from fishes in the ‘Old World’ to the ‘New World’, “Out Door Gardens’ and the ‘Big Blue’.

The Story of the Tuna Cage Continued

June 4, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

This morning we decided to launch the grey RIB (Rigid Inflatable Boat) into the ocean with Carlos Perez as the captain, myself (Keith Ellenbogen), photographer, Enrique Talledo, videographer; and Cesar Fuertes, deckhand to get close to the tuna cages and purseiner fishing boats.

From the RIB the Oceana Marviva is seen observing and documenting the French purseiner, Gerard Luc IV, ST 900236, transferring tuna into the cage.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Approaching the tuna cage in the RIB, one of the divers accelerated his zodiac within 1-2 meters of our boat. Carlos, an experienced veteran, called his bluff as though he had seen this a thousand times before. The diver curious about our intentions asked a few questions. Once satisfied with our answers he returned to his work of diving in the tuna cage and we continued image making. With all the tuna in the cage the tug boat (Antoni X, Panama; IMO 7033159) immediately set a course with the bluefin tuna to the fish farms.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In Melville’s time “…the sea rolled on as it rolled five thousand years ago”.

— Herman Melville, Moby Dick.

As the sun vanishes into the horizon with hunting bluefin tuna fishing boats and cages covering the Mediterranean, I wonder what the future will bring… And if life in the sea can roll on...

After 10 days in the Balearic Sea, we are now heading to Palma De Mallorca, Spain to pick-up scuba tanks, fix the compressor and replenish supplies before we press onward to Malta in two days.

Twenty-Eight Fishing Boats the Balearic Sea and The Giant Bluefin Tuna

June 3, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With the break of light, blue skies, calm seas and a watchful perched on the boats A-Frame, we continued to follow the two fishing vessels into the Balearic Sea. At 10 am this morning with no land in sight, 30 miles South of Formentera Island, I could hardly believe my eyes. As I gazed at the horizon all I saw was fishing boat after fishing boat. It was an orgy of tuna fishing boats in a mad rush to catch the bluefin tuna in the annual migration to spawn in the Mediterranean.

By the end of day we counted at least twenty-eight related bluefin tuna fishing boats in a 2 mile radius that included: purseiners, longliners, general fishing boats, tug-boats, Gardia Civil Patrol boat, and our boat, the Oceana Marviva with an international crew of concerned citizens for the marine environment. In addition to the larger fishing boats we also observed dozens of dingies, small auxiliary boats, and scuba divers.

As we arrived on scene, one of the French fishing boats (Marcal MA 146961) — I assume feeling the pressure of reaching and exceeding the fishing quota — vented his frustration by trying to intimidate us to leave. After blowing off some steam they moved onward.

Purseiners Fishing Technique

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Throughout the day we were able to document the process of purseiner fishing boats catching the Atlantic bluefin tuna and transferring them to tuna cages. This is a fishing operation in which the bluefin tuna concealed beneath the surface trapped, alive and in cages. The technique is for the purseiner fishing boats to locate schools of bluefin tuna. When the time is right they strike, by accelerating the boat in a large circle releasing the net to catch the fish. Once the fish are caught in the net they are transferred underwater to the cage — via a door that connects or joins the two nets. Using divers and lifting up the net the tuna are corralled into the cage. Once all the fish are transferred, the cage is hauled to the nearest fish farm using a tug boat.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

During the day we observed three purseiners transferring bluefin tuna to underwater cages. The process takes about 2-3 hours from start to finish. In one instance the purseiner fishing boat was not fast enough or missed a school of bluefin tuna. In this instance, instead of transferring the fish to a cage they hauled (using a crane) the struggling tuna out of water and into the boat where it was killed.

Throughout the night we remain at this location —in the center of the fishing fleet — to continue to monitor activities tomorrow.

Anchored and waiting

June 1, 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

On this Sunday morning the two French purseiner fishing boats Gerard Luc IV ST 900236 and Gerald Jean IV MA-916469 remain anchored in the Bay of Formentara Island. The only activity in the bay this morning was The Govern de les Illes Balears an environmental cleaning boat that was removing plastics or trash floating in the bay. On a positive note I have not noticed any garbage floating past our ship.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

Meanwhile onboard the MarViva Med we are all guessing what these fishing boats are doing. Xavier Pastor over dinner shared a few possible theories. Such as the fishing boats maybe tying to save fuel costs by only using only two boats to scout for the bluefin tuna. Once the fish are found they will call the other boats. But, he admits this is just a theory. Either way we wait patiently.

This afternoon, I photographed some of the equipment on the MarViva Med that I thought captured interesting forms and shapes.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The environment: bond with the sea

Do you know why the fishing season is from May to July?

Its because the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna migrate annually to the Mediterranean — in some instances traveling across the Atlantic Ocean for one reason — to reproduce. The giant Bluefin tuna are a remarkable fish and can live up to 15 years. Recent studies indicate that 50% of bluefin tuna don’t reach sexually maturity until they are 12 not 8 years old as was previously believed (NOAA). However, like clockwork as soon as the bluefin tuna arrive in the Mediterranean so do the fishing boats. As result of this over fishing, the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna are now listed on the “Critically Endangered Species List”. Animals on this list have an extremely high risk of becoming extinct.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Atlantic bluefin tuna have been an important part of Mediterranean culture for 12,000 years, and have been fished in the Mediterranean for at least 2,600 years — we would like this to continue for centuries to come.

What can be done to help?

Until sustainable management measures aligned with scientific advice are adopted - such as a closure of the fishing season in the crucial spawning month of June, and the reduction of fleet capacity – environmental organizations such as Oceana and WWF continue to urge for a moratorium of the fishery by ICCAT Contracting Parties, and for the boycott of trade and consumption of Mediterranean bluefin tuna by citizens, retailers, chefs and restaurateurs across the world.

Bonding with the sea

May, 31 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Many people ask me why we are following these purseiners bluefin tuna fishing boats? What do we hope to accomplish?

“Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It’s not” — Dr. Seuss, The Lorax

The first problem to address is tuna populations are seriously declining. These are not fabricated numbers or stories. It is real and worse yet really happening. Only two generations ago the tuna populations used to be healthy. Today they are in the eve of colapse.

What scientists, governments and non-profit organizations like Oceana are trying to do is enforce sustainable fishing quotas for a sustainable future. That is to say we want to maintain populations so that there will be bluefin tuna for future generations.

Check these facts out

• Beginning of May the Mediterranean fishing season opens

• An estimated, 10,000 bluefin tuna are caught each day by commercial fishermen.

• An estimated 27,000 tons of bluefin tuna will potentially have been caught by end of May.

• International Fishing Law permits 29,500 tons of bluefin tuna to be caught during the season from May – June.

• International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT, the body mandated to ensure the sustainable management of the Mediterranean bluefin tuna fishery), estimates that maximum catch should be of some 15,000 tones per year

(These facts were published by WWF in Bluefin Tuna Bulletin #47 May 23, 2008)

To put this number in perspective in less than one month of fishing it is estimated they caught 27,000 tons of bluefin tuna. This is virtually their entire quota in less than on month. For the entire season they are allowed to catch 29,500 tons of bluefin tuna. In simple terms its crazy. In fact this number is double what leading scientists consider sustainable fishing practice. At this rate there will be no tuna that can reach a size to breed to replenish their numbers.

Like an addict looking for his/her next fix the fisherman can not slow down their appetite to catch more and more of the bluefin tuna. In fairness it’s not just the fisherman but also the general publics demand.

What you can do?

I urge each of you to reduce your consumption for bluefin tuna

More to follow on the fishing industry as well as the habits and behaviors of what makes the bluefin tuna so special.

Expedition Log:

In the middle of the night we lost the purseiner fishing boats. This was not unexpected. Expedition leader Xavier Pastor thought that perhaps the fishing boats returned to Formentera Island late last night to anchor in the bay. With the break of light at 5:30 am the captain set our course direction back to Formentera Island. When we arrived at around 11 am the two purseiners (left, Gerald Jean IV MA-916469, Marseille; right, Gerard Luc IV ST 900236 were anchored in the bay.

For the rest of the afternoon we enjoyed swimming in the Mediterranean. One of the more exciting photographs today was a moment of luck — that revealed dive team member Alberto Iglesias’s head poking out a ball of small air bubbles after jumping off the side of the Oceana/Marviva into the blue, crystal clear, and relatively cold water.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Waiting

May, 30 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

With overcast skies and a slight sea breeze at around 8am two of the four purseiner fishing left the bay heading southeast. We decided to remain anchored and wait with the two other purseiner fishing boats.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

A Little Visitor

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

This morning, while waiting and watching the fishing boats, we were greeted by a cute little yellowish bird that perched itself on the blue/green rope high above the bow of the boat and on the railing of the observation deck.

Guardia Civil Helicopter

 

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At about 11 am the Guardia Civil helicopter flew overhead while we continue to remain anchored in the bay of Formentera Island.

The Fishing boats depart

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 1pm the second pair of purseiner fishing boats started their engines and began to motor out of the bay of Formentera Island. Captain Jani Forsgaard followed the boats southeast as we charted a course into the open ocean of the Balearic Sea.

While on the observation deck Jan Rautawaara TITLE proudly showed us this original brass magnetic compass in a mahogany case. He is a collector of vintage seafaring equipment and over the next few months is going to refurbish the equipment to its original state.

Soaring Gaviota

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

As our boat departed Formentera Island we were joined by a few Gaviota’s (seagulls) that seemed to enjoy soaring past the A-Frame at the boats stern to high above the observation deck. Then as if playing with the wind they turned there body 90 degrees fully extending their wings like a sail on a yacht and quickly glided behind our ship.

Secretaria General De Pesca

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At around 2pm with no land in sight the Secretaria General De Pesca (Inspeccion Pesquera) airplane flew overhead.

Tug Boat with Tuna Cages

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 3:30pm, 15 nautical miles southeast of Formentera Island we noticed the former bottom trawler Gasparillo, from La Vila Joiosa (3a AT.4.2.97) towing a tuna cage 50 meters in diameter. We are not sure if the cages are full or empty with bluefin tuna. However, we did notice the Gerald Jean IV MA-916469, Marseille pass very close to the tug boat. Despite our curiosity we continued moving southeast following our two targeted ships.

As the sun begins to set we have be underway for the past 7 hours and are now approximately 40 nautical miles from Formentera Island in the Balearic Sea.

Into the Night

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In the dark of the night and in the open sea at about 10:30 pm using radar equipment we navigated to a location near two-tug boats and one purseiner fishing boat. However, he concedes if the boats should decide to move in the night it will not be easy to follow them. It is our belief they will start fishing early tomorrow morning — more to follow…

The Four French Purseiners Depart Ibiza Harbour

May, 29 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

(Side note: Ibiza is spelled and pronounced ‘Eivissa’ in Catalan, the language of this Balearic Islands area.)

9:00 Pursainers Depart

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 9:00 am this morning the four French purseiner tuna fishing boats departed Ibiza harbor bearing a course of 120 degrees. Within minutes of noticing activity in the harbour Jani “Osku” Forsgaard the Captain of the Marviva/Oceana ship directed the crew to hoist-up the anchor set a course to follow the fishing boats.

Expedition Leader Xavier Pastor gathered the Oceana/Marviva team in the Captains Bridge and briefly implemented a strategy for following the fleet. During this briefing he addressed the two immediate concerns. One, what happens if we loose sight of the fishing boats? And two which of the four boat should we follow if the fleet separates…as he expects. Xavier emphasized that circumstances will dictate which vessel we follow but in the event we have to make a decision he would prefer to follow the blue purseiner fishing boats because their larger size.

10:15 – 10:30 We encounter Tug Boat and Tuna Cages

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Eight nautical miles Northeast of La Mola (island of Formentera) at 10:15am we sighted a tug boat with call numbers ‘EGDW’. The sighting of this tug boat with tuna cages (we assume still empty) is of particular significance as we believe it will be used to transfer and move the live tuna from the French Purseiners.

10:30 am Oceana team Watches the Fleet of Fishing Boats

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At 10:30 from the bridge and the observation deck the Oceana team watched the fishing boats circling a sea bank (peak depth 76meters) located 10 nautical miles NE of La Mala looking for bluefin tuna. For about an hour they circled this sea ban suggesting that the bluefin tuna may be near.

11:15 am The Wind Changes Direction

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

The wind begins to change direction and the seas start to become choppy. The search stops and the boats continue on a course of 120 degrees.

12:00 pm The Purseiners Anchor

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

At about noon (due to the possibility of rough seas outside) the following four purseiners anchored in Es Calo a bay of Formentera Island.

  • 1. Gerald Jean III, Port Vendres PV 916344
  • 2. Gerard Luc IV ST 900236
  • 3. Gerald Jean IV MA-916469, Marseille
  • 4. Gerard Luc III, ST 669329, Agde
© OCEANA / Alberto Iglesias

 

Shortly after all boats were anchored a fisheries patrol aircraft from the Secretaria General De Pesca Maritima (Fisheries Department, Spanish Government) flew overhead also monitoring activity in the area.

1pm Oceana Photographic/Videographic Team Prepares to go close to the Fishing Boats

Carlos Pérez, skipper of the Rigid Inflatable Boats (RIB) and Oceana’s Logistics Coordinator gathered team members: Cesar Fuertes, deckhand, Keith Ellenbogen, Photographer and Enrique Talledo, videographer. The purpose of this mission is to maneuver close to the boats and document any activity. With choppy waters and mild wind Carlos advised the Oceana team to prepare all photographic equipment against the probability and likelihood of getting wet from the oceans spray.

1:30 The RIB is Lowered into the Ocean

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Cesar Fuertes performs a final check on the engine on the RIB and the Marviva crew lowers the RIB into the ocean.

2:30 pm Carlos Perez Accelerates towards the Fishing Boats

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Alberto Iglesias
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With the communication equipment working, onboard the grey RIB, Carlos Perez a veteran of 20 years accelerated the boat through the water checking out its capabilities. As we approached within 30-40 meters of the fishing boats we did not notice any activity onboard their vessels. It is worth noting we are now preparing ourselves to maneuver close to these fishing boats to photographic their activities when the fleet begins to fish for bluefin tuna.

In the distance, the anchored Oceana/Marviva research vessel can be seen closely watching and monitoring the four French fishing boats.

8pm We are photographed

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

At 8pm just before the sunset a couple of men from the purseiner fishing boat number ST 669329 on a small skiff approached our boat to take a number of photographs.

We Wait…

May, 28 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

With the sea continuing to sway our boat from side to side like a pendulum we remained patiently anchored outside the harbor from sunrise to sunset — watching and waiting for the French purseiner fishing boats that are nearly out of sight to depart. At this point we are not sure for how long or why they are docked but we will continue to wait.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

As the sun descends behind Ibiza’s mountains I feel fortunate to enjoy the tranquility of time and this ‘buena vista’.

The Harbour of Ibiza, Spain

May, 27 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

On this overcast morning with occasional light rain we remained anchored just outside Ibiza’s harbor as a satellite communication equipment specialist came onboard the ship to install some necessary equipment. By mid afternoon with the break of the sun all our communication systems were successfully working.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

While anchored in the harbor of Ibiza we keep monitoring the four French purseiners docked in the largest pier of the port. In an area as overfished as this one, is outrageous that this kind of fishery is still allowed, even at the peak of the short tuna spawning season. Oceana and Marviva are strongly supporting a proposal by WWF to designate the waters around the Balearic Islands as a sanctuary, where no industrial fishing should be allowed. That proposal has received the formal support of a unanimous decision of the Balearic Islands Parliament and that of the Senate of Spain.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Pursainer fishing boats are of particular significance because they are one of the most destructive methods of fishing for bluefin tuna industry. This fishing technique is harmful for sustainable seas because it catches all most all the bluefin tuna with one ‘giant scoop’. The method of pursainer is to encircle the tuna spawning aggregations with a giant net and then close bottom trapping all the fish. The live tuna are then transferred to a tug-boat that travels slowly (2 knots) towing a holding pen where the tuna are constantly feed to bulk up before being killed and sold to market.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In aim to document the pursainers operations, expedition leader Xavier Pastor has decided that we will wait for the boats to set sail and lead us to their fishing grounds. Our hope is that they will leave tonight or tomorrow morning — but he suspects they will wait for better weather before departing. One of the challenges of following the pursainers is that they are two times as fast as our boat. However, once we know the general direction the pursainers are heading Xavier believes he will be able to calculate the possible location for bluefin tuna fishing.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In the late afternoon around 6 pm with the boat swaying from side to side we observed about a dozen bottom trawlers return to the harbor. Each boat and its call number was photographed and videographed for analysis.

As the sun set around 9pm the French pursainer fishing vessels remained docked in the harbor.

The Yellow RIB

May, 26 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

 

This morning was filled with excitement as we tested both of Oceana’s RIBs (rigid inflatable boats) for maneuverability to document legal and illegal bluefin tuna fishing boats in the Mediterranean. At 9am the crew of the Marviva Med lowered the 18ft yellow boat using a crane into the relatively calm ocean.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Captaining the boat was Oceana logistics coordinator Carlos Perez a veteran with over twenty years experience quickly maneuvering boats near fishing vessels for image-makers that could not otherwise be acquired. The zodiac expedition crew also consisted of photographer Keith Ellenbogen and videographer Enrique Talledo. Before departing the mother-ship Oceana’s expedition leader Xavier Pastor shouted “Buena suerte!” and off we went. While Carlos was testing this boats capabilities and communication equipment Keith and Enrique practiced steadying lens, focusing and keeping the camera dry from the spray of the ocean while Carlos speed through the waters. On this test run around Formentera Island, Spain no fishing boats were encountered.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Ibiza island

May, 26 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

In the afternoon the Marviva/Oceana research vessel sailed about one hour to anchor off the coast of Ibiza Island, Spain to pick-up some communication equipment and parts. From Oceana’s observation deck as well as the use of the zodiac into Ibiza’s marina we took pictures of the coastline and surveyed the waters identifying the following French tuna purseiners going into the harbour: “Gerald Jean IV” MA-916469, Marseille; “Gerald Jean III”, Port Vendres PV 916344; “Gerard Luc III” ST 669329; “Gerard Luc IV” ST 900236. A bit later, sharp at 6 pm, half a dozen bottom trawlers registered in Valencian harbours also entered the port of Ibiza, their temporary base.

Gerald Jean III
Gerald Jean IV
Gerard Luc III
Gerard Luc IV

A Fisherman’s catch — One Bluefin Tuna

May, 25 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

Our expedition began early this morning — with overcast skies and swelling seas — navigating the waters surrounding Formentera Island, Spain in a continued search for bluefin tuna fishing boats.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

During the course of the day we spotted two longline fishing vessels. They were the same ones we saw yesterday. But this time they were hauling in their gear. The technique of longline fishing is to release up to sixty or more kilometers of fishing line with thousands of individual baited hooks.

© OCEANA
© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

Before spotting the longline vessels, our first encounter was with yet another tuna cage towing tug, the Viking X, registered in Panama. Very soon after this we saw the Nuevo Isla Grande registered in Algeciras. Her sister ship, the Nuevo Isla Chica, was hauling in her line following a parallel course, a few miles away.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

When we arrived the men on the Nuevo Isla Grande were in the process of reeling in the longlines to harvest the catch. Oceana’s expedition leader Xavier Pastor asked our Finish Captain, Osko Forsgard to slow down our ship’s speed to observe and document what the fisherman were catching. For over an hour we watched as empty hook after hook was pulled onboard. In the final moments before deciding to move onward the fisherman aboard the Nuevo Isla Grande repositioned the boat to reel-in, with the aid of a gaff, one bluefin tuna approximately 5 ft or 1.5m in length.

The rest of the afternoon we continued search the waters of Formentera Island but no other fishing vessels were spotted.

May, 24 2008

Keith Ellenbogen - Underwater Photographer

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

 

Today Oceana’s MarViva Med a 160ft conservation research and diving vessel set off leaving behind the charming island of Palma De Mallorca, Spain where the boats in the marina and the masts on the yachts accentuate the beautiful cityscape.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Navigating our course south our expedition leader and Chief Scientist Xavier Pastor briefed the team on the importance of this expedition to photographically and videographically document the illegal tuna fishing practices in the Mediterranean — to insure a sustainable bluefin tuna fishery for future generations.

Only 60 miles South of the coast of Palma De Mallorca in relatively calm seas we approached our first bluefin tug boat towing at a very slow pace two large bluefin tuna cages that are approximately 200ft in diameter. The Valdivia was heading South, towards the fishing grounds close to Formentera island, where the tug boat will rende vouz with the tuna pursainers that will transfer their catches to the cages. There the fish will be fed and will grow until they are ready for being sent to the market. This technique is aimed at growing small bluefin tuna into larger tuna quickly.

© OCEANA / Keith Ellenbogen

Later in the day we spotted a second tuna cages tug, the Montroig, also heading South, in the vicinity of Emile Baudot Bank. Just before sunset, when we were already only a few miles from Formentera, we approached two longliners registered in Algeciras: Nuevo Isla Grande and her twin, Nuevo Isla Chica. They were sailing very slowly and no signs of fishing gear were seen onboard. They had already set their lines and they were waiting before starting the recovery of them, early morning tomorrow.

Please join our expedition over the next months as we highlight images from above and below ocean that focus on the joint project between Oceana and Mariviva to document bluefin tuna overexplotation and other illegal fishing practices.

Your comments and feed back are appreciated at europe@oceana.org